This fall a Manatee County, Florida importer getting ready to launch a battery-powered consumer product was quoted $10,000 for products liability insurance. By the rate, the premium should have been $1,125. The other $8,875 came from one sentence on the application, a line saying the battery cells had passed every test except one.

Two days after the underwriter read the full 37 page lab report behind that sentence, the same quote came back at $5,000. Nothing about the product changed. What changed was what the underwriter knew about the battery, and that is the whole story of insuring anything with a lithium pack in it.

The file

The business was new: no sales yet, no prior insurance, a product made overseas and sold under its own brand. Projected first year sales were $75,000. The owner had been told he needed "UL" on the battery, and he sent what the factory gave him.

What the factory gave him was a real document. It was a test report from an independent lab showing the pack had been tested to UL 2054, which UL Solutions titles the Standard for Household and Commercial Batteries, and that the cells inside were approved under UL 1642, the Standard for Lithium Batteries. Every clause tested passed.

It was not a certification. There was no file number on the pack. The trademark field on the report was blank, so nothing tied the tested pack to the brand on the box. And the report described the installation and use as "to be defined in final system," which means nobody had evaluated the finished product with the pack in it.

He also had a UN 38.3 test summary and asked whether that satisfied the requirement. It does not. UN 38.3 is the transport test. Federal hazardous materials rules require it before a lithium battery can be shipped at all. It says the pack can ride in a container. It does not say the product is safe to charge in a garage.

This office's first answer was no. The markets that write lithium products want three things: a certified pack with a file number, an evaluation of the end product, and the manufacturer's own products liability policy naming the US importer. He had none of the three, and no operating history on top of it.

The sentence

A wholesale broker thought one surplus lines carrier might look at it anyway, so the file went in. The battery section of the application repeated the lab report's wording: the cells "passed all tests except the projectile test."

The carrier quoted $15.00 per $1,000 of sales. On $75,000 that is $1,125. But the quote carried a $10,000 minimum premium, and the underwriter said in writing why: he had read the battery description and priced to that sentence. To him, "except the projectile test" read as a failed test. The quote also made the answer a condition of binding. Did the battery fail the projectile test, or was the test never performed?

The answer was in the report. The test had not been run. Once the underwriter read the actual document instead of a one line summary of it, the rate went to $10.00 per $1,000, the minimum premium went to $5,000, and the battery condition came off the quote.

The premium follows the wording, and the wording follows what the application said.

Tested to is not listed

There are three different things a seller can honestly say about a battery, and underwriters hear them very differently.

New York City wrote that difference into law. Local Law 39 of 2023 bars the sale of an e-bike unless its electrical system "has been certified by an accredited testing laboratory" to UL 2849, an e-scooter unless certified to UL 2272, and a replacement battery unless certified to UL 2271. The law says certified. A test report from the factory's lab does not meet it. Notice also that it does not require UL itself to do the certifying, only an accredited laboratory.

Never write "UL Listed" on an insurance application when what exists is a test report. If a fire claim comes in and the carrier finds the application overstated the certification, the fight stops being about the fire and starts being about the application.

Why underwriters are this careful

Under the federal Consumer Product Safety Act, a manufacturer is "any person who manufactures or imports a consumer product." If you bring it into the country under your brand, the law treats you as the maker.

And the fire record is public. The Consumer Product Safety Commission's April 2026 staff report counts lithium-ion battery fire deaths tied to e-scooters, hoverboards and e-bikes from 2017 through 2024: 15 deaths in 11 e-scooter incidents, 11 deaths in 5 hoverboard incidents, and 19 deaths in 13 e-bike incidents. That is 45 deaths in 29 fires. Seven of the e-bike deaths involved homemade battery packs or bike repair shops. In December 2022 the CPSC wrote to more than 2,000 manufacturers and importers telling them to comply with UL 2272 and UL 2849.

An underwriter looking at a new lithium product reads all of that before reading your application.

What the $5,000 bought

The cheaper quote was still not a standard policy, and an importer should read these terms before signing.

It was a claims-made form with the retroactive date set at inception. Nothing sold before the first day of the policy is covered, and a claim has to be made while a policy is in force.

The standard claims-made general liability form gives a basic extended reporting period of 60 days after the policy ends, stretched to five years for incidents reported within those 60 days. It also lets the insured buy an unlimited supplemental period for no more than 200 percent of the annual premium. This carrier's endorsement replaced all of that with a 30 day basic period, and a supplemental period with no stated length and no price cap that has to be requested and paid for within 30 days. A battery sold in year one can catch fire in year three. If the importer changes carriers or closes without buying that tail, year one is uninsured.

There was also a $2,500 deductible on every claim that applied to defense costs as well as damages, with defense costs paid inside the limit.

What to have before you ask for a quote

The point

On a lithium product the underwriter is pricing the paperwork, because the paperwork is the only evidence of what is inside the pack. A test report is not a certification, and one loose sentence about either one can double the premium or put the claim in doubt. Get the documents first, and describe them as exactly what they are.

Sources

Get a quote on this coverage.

Ten minutes on the application. Dennis reads it himself and responds the same business day in most cases.

Start the application →

Hendrickson Insurance, (941) 957-2796, [email protected], FL License E095547.

Coverage descriptions are general. Actual coverage is governed by the terms, conditions, and exclusions of the issued policy. Availability varies by carrier and by state.